Nothing demonstrate the failure of decades of Israeli and US policy in Palestine than the wave of hatred that is now consuming Israeli society. Now, 1,300 hundred Palestinian are dead and 7,000 wounded. They are overwhelmingly civilians (75-80%). Three
Israeli civilians have been killed—all of them after the Israeli attack began. Yet some 95% of the Jewish/Israeli public supports this lopsided carnage. Even genocide is being debated as if it were permissible. How did it come to this? The answer has much
to do with how hatred is being deliberately fanned in Israel—and with Israel’s deep sense of guilt for the crimes on which it is built and sustained.
When three Israeli teenagers were kidnapped and killed in mid-June, Netanyahu immediately blamed Hamas and promoted the pretence that the boys were still alive. (This is an arbitrary starting point—just a day before, a Palestinian man and child had been killed without any similar outcry.) In the following 11 days, Israel’s
military killed about ten Palestinians and arrested almost 600 hundred more.
In the weeks of public hysteria in Israel that followed, Netanyahu repeatedly used the language of incitement and hatred.
In Israel, a day before Palestinian teenager Muhammad Abu Khudair was kidnapped and burned alive by six Israeli Jewish youths, Ayelet Shaked, a Palin-esque young member of the
Knesset, wrote on her Facebook page that, “the entire Palestinian people is the enemy” and justified its destruction, “including its elderly and its women, its cities and its villages, its property and its infrastructure.” She also called for the slaughter of Palestinian mothers who give birth to “little snakes.” She explained:
…They have to die and their houses
should be demolished so that they cannot bear any more terrorists…they are all
our enemies and their blood should be on our hands. This also applies to the
mothers of the dead terrorists.”
In its immediate response to the lynching/murder of Abu Khudair, Israel claimed that there was no evidence that it was a “hate crime.” Israeli police then arrested and beat a young visiting American cousin of Abu Khudair. This hate crime was caught on
video. The young American was held under house arrest and his family “detained.” The police who beat the boy are apparently still free. Yet still Israeli hatred grows. A hate site founded in response to the kidnapping of the three Israeli teens was then getting a thousand likes a minute in Israel.
Then, on the night of 6 July, Israel struck in Gaza, killing seven Hamas “militants.” And only then, with the existing ceasefire clearly broken by Israel, did Hamas rocket fire escalate.
We are now over 22 days
into the resulting carnage. Over 1,100 Palestinians have been killed and over
6,000 wounded. None of them lived on the West Bank where the Israeli teens were
killed. In all of 2013, up to the Israeli attack of July 6th, zero
Israeli civilians had been killed by Hamas rockets. At this point, there are
only three civilian deaths in Israel.
Yet the hatred and bloodlust of Israel rages unchecked. A YouTube video from July 28th shows Israelis demonstrating in favor of the current operation by gleefully chanting (roughly translated), “There is no school in Gaza tomorrow—all the
children are dead.” Israeli military officials deny that Israel is responsible for civilian casualties—yet military officials privately refer to the policy of “mowing the lawn” — a hate filled Israeli euphemism for violently, indiscriminately, and regularly “pruning” the Hamas leadership. Reports show that Israelis watch the bombing from their lawn chairs, cheering and applauding each time a target in Gaza explodes. They share popcorn and describe the event as “just good fun.”
Now the hatred has spread to
America. Yesterday, RabbiDavid-Seth Kirshner, (an executive of the NY Board of Rabbis) claimed that Palestinians who voted for Hamas are combatants who deserve to be targeted by Israel. He said:
When you are part of an election process that asks for a
terrorist organization which proclaims in word and in deed that their primary
objective is to destroy their neighboring country and not to build schools or
commerce or jobs, you are complicit and you are not a civilian casualty.
Ironically, the
rabbi’s words apply more aptly to the Israeli leadership which occupies Gaza
than to Hamas. Israel’s siege of Gaza has involved the destruction of
everything listed above. His words are an eerie echo of Osama Bin Laden’s claim
that ‘there are no innocent American civilians because America elected an
oppressive government.’ So (according to the Rabbi) if you voted for Hamas,
Israel has a right to kill you! The fact
is, of the 1.8 million people in Gaza, about 15,000 (8%) are actually members
of Hamas. About 440,000 voted for Hamas, 414,000 for Fatah and other roughly
one million didn’t vote at all. You
think we should help Israel kill them all?
Finally, the hatred spawned by Israel becomes the very
face of America’s government.
The Senate just voted 100-0 to approve S. Res. 498.
The bland bureaucratic faces of these Senators, and the media pundits who daily
approve them and mouth the talking points of Israel’s cadre of professional
liars, are the very picture of Hannah Arendt’s famous phrase about the
“banality of evil.”
Israel’s hatred has overflowed. America has embraced
it. This is exactly why our founding fathers warned us against entering into
‘entangling foreign alliances.’ They
knew that so called “special relationships” have a special power to corrupt. We
don’t need “special relationships” with countries like Israel. We need decent,
ethical and practical relationships that promote peace. By that standard, all
US aid to Israel should immediately be cut off, the Israeli leadership should
be held accountable for war crimes, and sanctions should be imposed on Israel
until they abide by all the many UN resolutions and international laws they are
in violation of. (Please notice I am NOT calling for the killing of all Israelis
who voted Netanyahu into office.)
Of course you may say, “There is hatred on the
Palestinian side as well.” There certainly is, but that is the angry hatred
that comes from the real violence, dispossession and oppression that has been
inflicted on them by Israel over the years—it is rooted in honest anger.
The hatred I see in Israel and its supporters is
different. It reeks of bad conscience. It is an ever deepening sewer fed by a
guilt that silently corrodes the shaky foundations of the state and the whole
Zionist project that spawned it. It threatens Israel’s cherished goal of
attaining “legitimacy”—even in its own jaded eyes. The deaths of three
teenagers, however tragic, could never unleash this torrent of hatred in a
country that was not already deeply in the grip of a virulent disease. It is
absurd to talk, as some pundits have done lately, about ‘hatred on the fringes
of Israeli society.’ The hatred is at the core—in the government, the military,
and the 95% of Jewish Israelis whom (polls now show) support Netanyahu’s
current policy.
Today a serious op-ed in “The Times of Israel” debated
the notion that genocide permissible. The very fact that this question is now
openly being debated in Israel says all we need to know about the hatred
consuming that country.
It’s tragic to see how that foreign hatred is
polluting our own country: to see so many people choosing to hate. One can feel
pity for them—but that doesn’t mean we need to buy into their hatred and lies.
In fact, we must not. For us there is still time to stop and think. After all,
there are no “chosen people.” We are simply what we choose to make of
ourselves. No one forced Israel to start this war.
“Gilbert Schramm is a
peace activist and international educator who currently lives in Oregon. He has
previously lived and worked extensively in the Middle East and has studied the
region for almost 35 years.”
